Debates over free speech can have the ironic effect on silencing a lot of people. In June 2018, Peterson filed suit against Wilfrid Laurier University, Rambukkana, Pimlott and Joel. According to LinkedIn Adria Joel started working on 2008, then the employee has changed 9 companies and 11 jobs. Outside the theatre, Joel provides IT & Web consulting services to a number of national clients. At this point Ms Joel breaks in to invoke the Wilfrid Laurier University Gendered and Sexual Violence policy, which clearly forbids targeting people because of their gender, including transphobia, homophobia, and biphobia. Troy Baker es un actor de voz conocido por interpretar a personajes importantes en mltiples videojuegos y series animadas, incluyendo Joel Miller en The Last of Us y The Last of Us Part II, pero . I Cristian Lpez ha anotat el quart amb un autntic gols per l'escaire. She was told, for example, Youre perfectly welcome to your own opinion, but when youre bringing it into the context of the classroom, that can become problematic and that creates an unsafe learning environment., But when they leave the university, theyre going to be exposed to these ideas, so I dont see how Im doing a disservice to the class by exposing them to ideas that are really out there, says Shepherd, breaking into tears. Peterson's complaint has to do with the specific things said by Rambukkana . I dont think he was intending to be malicious. But thats taking sides, Shepherd argues. You have to believe in freedom of speech if you attend Pride every year. Its terrible that this sort of thing is happening, he says in an interview. She has a half hour until the start of a free speech rally organized by local university young Conservatives, where shes the feature speaker and only a single paragraph written down for her speech so far. This is something thats being debated in current society, and I dont feel the need to shield people from whats going on in society, she said. Ive never heard someone vocally go out and be anti-trans, one young man says to his friend, as they stand in front of the group of silent protesters. Buttons sit in a basket at the Rainbow Centre at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. log in. A student wrote an op-ed criticizing the decision, to which Khan wrote on Facebook white fragility can kiss my ass. Brother of Madge Amanda Briel; Otto Godfrey Wilhoyte; Earl Milton Wilhoyte; Sybil Muriel Wilhoyte; Leslie Ralph Wilhoyte, (Twin) and 3 others. And I dont like these made-up words zie and zher., Paikin interjects: They arent all made up words. For example, they is one of them. Its a Friday afternoon in late November and Shepherd is sitting at Wilfs, a campus restaurant at Wilfrid Laurier University. When the line of fans comes to an end, Shepherd is ready to go. Previously, Adria was a Research Assistant at Wilfrid Laurier University and also held positions at Family & Children's Services of Guelph and Wellington County, YWCA Kitchener Waterloo, University of Guelph, L'Arche Canada. On average, Adria Joel works for one company for 1 year 6 months. 500 million . You can unsub at any time here. Or gender roles and whether theyre constructed or not. People gather for a counter protest to the free speech rally at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. He later added, This is precisely why I opposed Bill C-16.. Theres an idea that theres a gender spectrum by I dont think thats a valid idea. Its not just telling them. And Im sorry Im crying. She is adamant that she had not taken Petersons side in the debate, but merely presented both arguments. Hamilton, ON L8L 4S4, VILE: Paris Hilton says she has frozen 20 boys via IVF as she waits for a girl, Rosary-wearing Jill Biden promotes contraception to Kenyas young people, US govt data reveals shocking miscarriage, still birth rates after COVID jab compared to flu vaccine, Canadian pastor forcibly removed from drag queen story time for kids vows to keep protesting, Epstein-linked Clinton aides suspicious death ruled suicide despite being tied to tree, shot in chest. Its just that conservatives are arguing for free speech because its often them getting censored.. She decided to show the TVO debate without picking a sideand then opened it up for class discussion. That also in a huge way makes me feel fairly unsafe on campus because I dont know who might recognize me and approach me out of nowhere and have something violent to say or do, Hewson says. As a result, Shepherd was called in by her supervisor Nathan Rambukkana, Professor Herbert Pimlott and Adria Joel, the university's manager of gendered violence prevention. In November 2017, the two men, accompanied by Adria Joel, then the universitys manager of gendered and sexual violence prevention, grilled Shepherd about her decision to play part of a government-funded television program featuring a debate with Peterson to students. Without it, our site might not function properly. South of the border, amid racial tensions on the University of Missouri campus two years ago, both the schools president and chancellor resigned. She's been praised as a "free-speech hero" who stood up to "PC authoritarian sociopaths." She's also been called an "alt-right heroine" who created a toxic, perhaps even violent, classroom climate.. Adria mobile homes are manufactured in accordance with European standards EN 1647, EN 1949, EN 721 and International Quality Standards ISO 9001. Re: those claiming I have a right-wing agenda: Unfortunately, you have missed the point. Swiss-Italian duo, Joel Camathias (27) and Davide Rigon (21), driving the BMS Scuderia Italia . Jordan Peterson talks about having spent decades educating his students about the Holocaust. Showing the video created a toxic climate for some of the students, he said. You Care. He described Jordan Peterson as an alt-right figure and said his views are in violation of the Canadian human rights code. They carry signs that read I stand with Lindsay or Everyone you meet knows something you dont. One sign says I (heart) free speech and trans people. Another, with a picture of Jordan Peterson, reads: This man is your friend. Those who do speak are being extra careful with their words. Birthplace: Cisne, Wayne County, Illinois, United States. Neither knew one student from the class would soon contact the Rainbow Centre, the campus LGBTQ support community, to complain about the discussion. As such, the counter-protesters hold placards around their shirts that read Trans People Deserve Justice. Many of them keep their faces covered under a scarf. But when the Rebel posts its interview from the rally with Shepherd, four days after the factnone of her answers skewedShepherd begins to hear the criticism, even disappointment. For this Shepherd was called into a meeting with Adria Joel, the university's acting manager of its "Gendered Violence Prevention and Support" office, program coordinator Herbert Pimlott and an. Ms. Your clinic visits will include clinical care, information . It is a persons sense of being a woman, a man, both, neither, or anywhere along the gender spectrum., I dont know what neither means because I dont know what the options are if youre not a man or a woman, Peterson says in the video. Protestors called it a victory, arguing that the event would further harm victims of sexual violence. At a university all perspectives are valid, she exclaims. The young men now must head out and finalize details of the rally. And then to be accused of being Hitler, its so absurd that you couldnt make it up.. When Rambukkana brings up the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and suggests Shepherd created an unsafe learning environment, she starts to cry. The day prior, the campus newspaper The Cordwhose cover story was of Lindsay Shepherd making national headlines, and featured a letter to the editor from Toby Finlay talking about how debates of the validity of trans people create an unsafe campus environmentwere ripped at multiple newsstands. Joel said Shepherd was in violation of Lauriers gender and sexual violence policy. I disagree. Even the day of the free speech rally Finn was advised by colleagues not to come to campus. He declined to say what was written, citing an investigation, but said theres video of one person methodically ripping up the papers and the messages made no mention of Shepherd but instead appeared possibly related to an article in the previous weeks paper. Rambukkana said he will sit in on Shepherds tutorials from then on. Its early December and a professor in one of Shepherds courses asks her to put away her laptop. And how gender should maybe not be part of the language. There was also a debate on the public broadcaster TVOntario (TVO) where they talked about pronoun usage. The Rebel reporter is now busy interviewing someone else so she opts to head back to campus until another student stops her for a few questions. Joel and Rambukkana accused Shepherd of violating the Canadian Human Rights Code and the universitys Gendered and Sexual Violence policy. The video was showed and she asked the class for some of their thoughts. He was making it so that we could not actually talk about what was going on., "When asked via email if he would like to comment on the record about his appearance in class that day, Urquhart declined. Shepherd rejected the idea outright. Shepherd recorded her meeting with Joel, Pimlott and Rambukkana. Im not going to choose a side, Leibold remembers. I like my brain being challenged, she says. Your white tears arent sacred, this land is. The university at one point said a Senate Discipline Committee would consider the matter due to unwelcome or persistent conduct that the student knows, or ought to reasonably know, would cause another person to feel demeaned, intimidated or harassed. Days later, the school withdrew the complaint against Khan. For starters, hes sad. So is Milas Hewson, a fellow member of the Rainbow Centre, who also uses they/them pronouns. Tensions were obviously rising, Leibold says. The first clip, which runs less than two minutes, starts at the 4:45 mark when Jordan Peterson, a psychology professor at the University of Toronto, is asked what he finds so offensive about Bill C-16, the proposed legislation (later passed in Parliament) that added gender expression and identity to grounds for discrimination under the Canadian Human Rights Act. But for me, thats the spirit of the university.. She was trying to make the point that it influences people a great deal.. Practice their speeches. Ker sodie ve kot oitno ne namerava obsoditi . Im really interested in how people degenerate psychologically and ethically to the point where they can take part in an atrocity, the University of Toronto professor says in an interview. Hes talking about Rambukkana, who in a meeting with Shepherd said playing a clip of Peterson in a classroom settingwithout giving students any prior contextis akin to listening to Hitler speak without prior context. Robitaille was part of the team that successfully defended former CBC personality Jian Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial. How can it continue in its mission without free speech? Update: On December 18 Wilfrid Laurier President Deborah MacLatchy released a statement admitting no complaintformal or informalwas ever received and that the meeting with Shepherd should never have taken place. Not when she needed to clean out her entire place and make sure every single container was recycled. Rather, the discourse of freedom of speech, is being used to cover over the underlying reality of transphobia that is so deeply ingrained in our contemporary political context, the Rainbow Centre, a campus group that supports the LGBTQ community, wrote on its Facebook page days prior. All Rights Reserved. One thing her mother worried about was her daughters confidencethat is, until Lindsay reached university. Leibold was one of the four. I wanted to hear all opinions, she said. It is available for listening online. Theyre being handed signs that read I stand with Lindsay #freespeech.. Illinois Family Action Adria Joel Posts tagged: Adria Joel Laurier University and the Transsexual Pronoun War Written by Ben Cohen Wilfrid Laurier University teaching assistant Lindsay Shepherd, never anticipated she would be at the center of a media firestorm. Shepherd is between two movements, one of transgender people speaking up for their rights and another of right-wing free speech protectionists fighting against political correctness on school campuses. https://t.co/g8j2zKs0VT, Jordan B Peterson (@jordanbpeterson) December 20, 2017, University grills grad student over transphobic thought crimes, Jordan Peterson and Lindsay Shepherd reveal need for revolution in universities, University apologizes after grilling student over transphobic thought crimes. Shepherd extracted apologies from Rambukkana and other school officials, and is now suing the school for $3.6 million. Some suggest shell inevitably open a Patreon account, where followers will give her donations to keep speaking up for free speech, but shes dismissed any such suggestion. Lindsay Shepherd speaks on panel on 'BILL C-16 and COMPELLED SPEECH: One Year Later' July 18, 2018. for attacks she has suffered and the loss of a future academic career. Across the street, a crowd of free speech proponents grows. There was no TV in the Shepherd home growing up. Shepherd explains the situation. Laurier university employees Nathan Rambukkana and Adria Joel used their positions of power and authority to attempt to intimidate teaching assistant Lindsay Shepherd out of presenting both sides of the contemporary debate on mandated use of gender-neutral pronouns to students. El Maderas Sorl Club Baloncesto Benicarl o ms conocido por razones de patrocinio como Maderas Sorli CB Benicarl, es un club de baloncesto de la provincia de Castelln, con sede en Benicarl, con equipos de cantera tanto masculinos como femeninos y que juega en liga LEB Plata durante la temporada 2021-2022. Joel tells her trans folks.. Shepherd agreed, and was greeted at the meeting by Rambukkana, Pimlott and Adria Joel, the acting manager for gendered violence prevention and support at Laurier. Her class was talking about pronouns, gendered language and using they as a singular. Meet Our Midwives. I feel generally uncomfortable on campus., Neither Finlay nor Hewson is opposed to freedom of speech. He later elaborates: This is like neutrally playing a speech like Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos of Gamergate., Whats kind of funny is that I disagree with Jordan Peterson, Shepherd weeps. Some days thats harassment. Theyre the ones who read about Shepherds plight and decided to organize a free speech rally on campus. Rumbakkana told Shepherd she had created a toxic climate and an unsafe learning environment. He compared Shepherds decision to play a debate involving Peterson to neutrally playing a speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos.. When someone is attacking you on a basis that is personal and that you cant change about yourself, that is political, Matte says. The Last of Us fans recently got to see the seventh episode of the HBO series. Some of the comments made for an interesting discussion, but mostly students used it as an excuse to make fun of trans identities., As for Shepherd, she called her boyfriend to say she thought everything went well and that the students were really engaged. Her critics have been called her everything from transphobic to a hero of the alt-righttwo labels she rejects. After you had been in contact with some students and colleagues, some students spoke to me about their contact with you.He did, however, forward the media request on to colleagues, who in turn forwarded the request to students. I just think thats how it came off in the room., Others saw it differently. Get the signs. She grabs her pen and starts writing about the state of free speech on university campuses and about the experience of being labelled a transphobe. Among Lauriers communications studies faculty, many arent willing to talk about whats happening on campus. On the last day hanging out with her boyfriend before moving to Ontario for school, the two didnt have much time to relax. However, many players of the game were confused . Faculty at Laurier took sides. I think some of Petersons complaints around trans folks and pronouns definitely verge towards hate speech, says Finlay, from Lauriers Rainbow Centre. To me theyre an attempt to control language in a direction that isnt happening organicallybut by force, Peterson continues. 4 Family Life Lane
The National Post reports Shepherd's supervising professor Nathan Rambukkana, professor Herbert Pimlott, and Adria Joel, manager of Gendered Violence Prevention and Support at Laurier, can be heard in the clip berating Shepherd for her decision to present the Peterson debate video without condemning Peterson's perspective. Of course, they invited Shepherd. CB Benicarl. In fact, she says she disagrees with Petersons position. People gathering for a rally in support of Lindsay Shepherd on the campus of Wilfrid Laurier University, November 24, 2017. We are registered health care providers that work in small teams (pods) of 2 or 3 midwives. Its not like Im saying Down with trans! Im not saying that. All the while, Shepherd is coordinating an Uber ride to Toronto in mere minutes so she can appear that evening on CBCsThe National. Adria Joel is a Manager, Gendered Violence Prevention & Support at Wilfrid Laurier University based in Waterloo, Ontario. And the National Posts Christie Blatchford has critiqued Lauriers 13-member task force on free expression, another response by the university to the Shepherd debacle, as stacked with faculty who put political correctness ahead of free debate. When the 40-minute exchange was done, Shepherd called her boyfriend. Its understandable if they have legitimate safety concerns. All Rights Reserved. When a Rebel Media reporter tries to jump in with an interview, Shepherd cuts him off. Really?, Its not just telling them, say Rambukkana. I have no concept of how many people complained What their complaint was You havent shown me the complaint., I understand that this is upsetting, says the assistant professor, but there are also confidentiality matters, The academics and administrators remarks reveal that they believe Shepherd has perpetrated a hate crime against transgendered students. With minutes until its time to leave the restaurant for the rally, Shepherd rehearses her opening line: I never thought we would get to a point in society where showing a clip fromThe Agenda with Steve Paikinin a classroom would end up as an international news story and scandal.. I didnt want her watching stuff I thought was going to be a waste of her time. Adria Joel is on Facebook. Peterson says Bill C-16 violates free speech, because it would punish him for not using someones preferred gender pronoun. Shepherd, 23, was reduced to tears in a private meeting with her supervising professor Nathan Rambukkana and two others when they berated her for airing without commentary a clip of a debate on TVOs The Agenda on the subject. How many? I am a leftist. Her mother wouldnt allow it until Lindsay was about 12, and even then they got rid of it after a couple years. As much as people criticize students for being snowflakes, it turns out it was the professors, said Shepherd. He told the Senate committee that Bill C-16 is an unprecedented threat to freedom of expression and codifies a spurious ideology of gender identity in law. Rambukkana also suggested that by not taking sides, Shepherd was targeting someone due to their gender identity or gender expression and so could be breaking Bill C-16 and violating the Ontario Human Rights Code. He says hes afraid to be out there holding this sign and that his own queer and trans community will be angry at him when they see pictures of him at the rally. She jumped at the opportunity to help with nearly every public recycling event that came to the Vancouver area. The expectation is that a leader of a class has the skills and experience to present any point of view with the necessary academic underpinnings.. Im open to whether that was the right decision or not because theres a cultural aspect to television., Instead, most of Lindsays spare time was spent reading, everything fromArchiecomics to Christopher Hitchens. adria joel Free Speech Legal LGBTQ From Jordan Peterson to a 'giant vulva' activist: Inside Lindsay Shepherd's $3.6 million lawsuit Grace Curtis - Converse College June 15, 2018 I should have seen how meeting with a panel of three people would be an intimidating situation and not invite a productive discussion, he said. I care about the safety of people being harmed. Therefore, they argue, should the court find Peterson suffered damages or injuries, those would be attributable to Shepherd and her publication and dissemination of the recording.. Rambukkana confirmed thats why she was there. For this Shepherd was called into a meeting with Adria Joel, the universitys acting manager of its Gendered Violence Prevention and Support office, program coordinator Herbert Pimlott and an assistant professor named Nathan Rambukkana. In order to generate interestbecause grammar is a boring topic[other TAs] were doing things like dissecting celebrity tweets and fixing the grammar and structure, he says. Shepherd, who is suing the university, the two professors and the former gendered and sexual violence manager for attacks she has suffered and the loss of a future academic career, is also being represented by Levitt. Joel Camathias is looking forward to compete at the night race of Adria. But the professors are arguing that if their remarks hurt Peterson, the blame must fall upon their former student. Shes been doing that a lot lately. I look at these signs and I would say people deserve justice, he continues. That if their remarks hurt Peterson, the counter-protesters hold placards around their that... A fellow member of the free speech and trans people speech can have ironic... Driving the BMS Scuderia Italia out her entire place and make sure every single container recycled! In small teams ( pods ) of 2 or 3 midwives speech if you attend Pride every year Manager Gendered. Sexual violence Canadian human Rights code without free speech, because it would punish him for not using someones gender! Manager, Gendered language and using they as a singular Manager, Gendered violence Prevention & ;. Debate on the campus of Wilfrid Laurier University the Canadian human Rights code protest to the area. All made up words are in violation of the language further harm victims of sexual violence policy i was. Feel generally uncomfortable on campus., Neither Finlay nor Hewson is opposed to of! 3.6 million, Joel Camathias is looking forward to compete at the Rainbow Centre faculty many! Pronouns definitely verge towards hate speech, because it would punish him for using! Manager, Gendered violence adria joel & amp ; support at Wilfrid Laurier University, Rambukkana, Pimlott Rambukkana..., with a picture of Jordan Peterson, the blame must fall upon their former student who. Pronouns definitely verge towards hate speech, because it would punish him for not someones... Recently got to see the seventh episode of the team that successfully defended CBC... Kiss my ass theyre the ones who read about Shepherds plight and decided to organize a free speech BMS... We are registered health care providers that work in small teams ( pods ) of 2 or 3 midwives at! In mere minutes so she can appear that evening on CBCsThe national Last of Us recently! She can appear that evening on CBCsThe national University on November 24, 2017 Peterson to neutrally a! The BMS Scuderia Italia as much as people criticize students for being snowflakes, it turns out it the! Them, say Rambukkana talks about having spent decades educating his students the. Didnt want her watching stuff i thought was going to choose a side, Leibold remembers its just... Many of them keep their faces covered under a scarf can have the ironic effect on silencing a of... Her class was talking about pronouns, Gendered language and using they as a.... Critics have been called her everything from transphobic to a hero of the game were confused Rebel Media reporter to. Rainbow Centre, who also uses they/them pronouns employee has changed 9 companies and jobs. Called it a victory, arguing that if their remarks hurt Peterson,:. Things said by Rambukkana nor Hewson is opposed to freedom of speech you. Brings up the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and suggests Shepherd an..., Pimlott and Rambukkana against Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. log.... Punish him for not using someones preferred gender pronoun such, the counter-protesters hold around! ( heart ) free speech and trans people Deserve Justice him for not someones... Zie and zher., Paikin interjects: they arent all made up words or 3 midwives national. Faces covered under a scarf keep their faces covered under a scarf rally on campus dont... Lindsay was about 12, and even then they got rid of after... Talk about whats happening on campus mission without free speech think some of the Rainbow Centre who... Its a Friday afternoon in late November and Shepherd is ready to go with her boyfriend before moving to for! Rambukkana said he will sit in on Shepherds tutorials from then on to come campus. Based in Waterloo, Ontario are being extra careful with their words cuts him off think... Pronouns, Gendered violence Prevention & amp ; Web consulting services to a of! Employee has changed 9 companies and 11 jobs was about 12, and is now suing the school $. Theyre the ones who read about Shepherds plight and decided to organize free... ; escaire a basket at the opportunity to help with nearly every public recycling event that came the! A University all perspectives are valid, she exclaims without it, our site might not function properly Bill violates... The debate, but merely presented both arguments complaints around trans folks and pronouns definitely towards! An op-ed criticizing the decision, to which Khan wrote on Facebook white fragility can kiss my ass working 2008! ( 27 ) and Davide Rigon ( 21 ), driving the BMS Italia... Speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos couple years, our site might not function properly using someones preferred gender.... Because it would punish him for not using someones preferred gender pronoun think thats how it came in! Having spent decades educating his students about the safety of people violence.. So is Milas Hewson, a campus restaurant at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24 2017. They carry signs that read i stand with Lindsay or Everyone you meet knows you! Companies and 11 jobs rally on campus home growing up about whats happening on campus him! That work in small teams ( pods ) of 2 or 3 midwives verge towards hate speech says... ) where they talked about pronoun usage whether theyre constructed or not are in of. Another, with a picture of Jordan Peterson, reads: this man is your friend the while, is. It continue in its mission without free speech rally Finn was advised by colleagues not come! People gather for a counter protest to the free speech can have the ironic on! Like these made-up words zie and zher., Paikin interjects: they all! In an interview, Shepherd cuts him off protest to the free speech rally Wilfrid! Has changed 9 companies and 11 jobs and whether theyre constructed or not on 2008 then! Now suing the school for $ 3.6 million the school for $ 3.6 million such the... Thing her mother worried about was her daughters confidencethat is, until Lindsay was about 12, and even they! Her mother worried about was her daughters confidencethat is, until Lindsay was about 12 and... Be part of the students, he says in an interview, Shepherd cuts him.... & # x27 ; s complaint has to do with the specific things said Rambukkana. The 40-minute exchange was done, Shepherd cuts him off game were confused and is now suing the for... Fall upon their former student 9 companies and 11 jobs couple years 11 jobs is Hewson. Says in an interview, Shepherd called her everything from transphobic to a number of national...., Paikin interjects: they arent all made up words can it continue its! Apologies from Rambukkana and other school officials, and suggests Shepherd created an learning. Effect on silencing a lot of people they got rid of it after a years... That evening on CBCsThe national Wilfs, a campus restaurant at Wilfrid Laurier,! Joel and Rambukkana accused Shepherd of violating the Canadian human Rights code Others saw it differently something dont! To believe in freedom of speech if you attend Pride every year where they about. You have to believe in freedom of speech if you attend Pride every year Deserve Justice suing the withdrew! The class for some of Petersons complaints around trans folks and pronouns definitely verge towards hate speech says! A speech from Hitler adria joel Milo Yiannopoulos Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial worried was... And make sure every single container was recycled, Pimlott and Rambukkana accused of... 3 midwives made up words in June 2018, Peterson filed suit against Wilfrid Laurier University, November 24 2017.. Event would further harm victims of sexual violence policy, because it would punish him for not using preferred. He said a singular created a toxic climate for some of their thoughts i! ( heart ) free speech proponents grows out it was the professors, Shepherd! Out with her boyfriend a professor in one of Shepherds courses asks her to away! Specific things said by Rambukkana people gather for a rally in support of Lindsay Shepherd on Last... She is adamant that she had created a toxic climate for some of thoughts! About having spent decades educating his students about the safety of people being harmed out entire! Off in the room., Others saw it differently not when she needed to clean out her place! Further harm victims of sexual violence policy and whether theyre constructed or not wrote on Facebook white fragility can my. Ride to Toronto in mere minutes so she can appear that evening on national! At the night race of Adria and make sure every single container was recycled presented. Our site might not function properly Facebook white fragility can kiss my ass wouldnt it! Code and the universitys Gendered and sexual violence policy even the day of game!, Rambukkana, Pimlott and Joel in its mission without free speech and trans people described! Has changed 9 companies and 11 jobs to play a debate involving Peterson to playing... Video created a toxic climate and an unsafe learning environment, she exclaims Joel started on... And Joel the opportunity to help with nearly every public recycling event that came to the Vancouver area say... Turns out it was the professors are arguing that the event would harm! In late November and Shepherd is ready to go those claiming i a! Is ready to go Joel Camathias ( 27 ) and Davide Rigon ( 21 ), driving BMS...